This room is open to everyone: crew, actors, programmers and people who simply love films. The conversations that work best here are about how a film is made, so a few habits. House habits - Put SPOILERS on the first line if you discuss an ending. - Name the scene, and a rough timecode if you have it. - Credit the department: say who shot it, cut it, mixed it. - Be specific. 'The cut lands a beat before the cymbal' teaches more than 'great editing'. - Facts about awards, years and credits get a source. Four films to start on - Children of Men (2006), directed by Alfonso Cuarón, shot by Emmanuel Lubezki. Long handheld takes and very little traditional film lighting. Lubezki won the ASC Award for it and was nominated for the Oscar. - Whiplash (2014), directed by Damien Chazelle. Tom Cross won the Oscar for Best Film Editing, and the BAFTA too. Watch how the cuts land on the drums. - The Zone of Interest (2023), directed by Jonathan Glazer. Sound designer Johnnie Burn and production sound mixer Tarn Willers won Best Sound at the 96th Academy Awards in March 2024; the film also won Best International Feature. The camp is mostly heard and almost never seen. - Sinners (2025), directed by Ryan Coogler, shot by Autumn Durald Arkapaw on 65mm film in Ultra Panavision 70 and IMAX. In March 2026 she became the first woman to win the Oscar for Best Cinematography. Questions to bring to any rewatch - Where is the camera, and why there? - How long does the shot last, and what would a cut have changed? - What do you hear that you never see? - What colour is skin, and what colour is the night? Sources: - American Society of Cinematographers, Children of Men, https://theasc.com/articles/children-of-men-humanitys-last-hope - American Society of Cinematographers, Sinners, https://theasc.com/article/sinners-cinematography-durald-arkapaw/ - National Film and Television School, The Zone of Interest Oscar for Best Sound, https://nfts.co.uk/article/nfts-location-sound-alumni-wins-oscar-best-sound-zone-interest
On Whiplash: Tom Cross first cut a short version of the film that Chazelle used to raise the money for the feature, so the two of them had rehearsed the rhythm before a frame of the feature was shot. If you want vocabulary for why a cut feels right, Walter Murch's 'In the Blink of an Eye' ranks the reasons: emotion first at 51 percent, then story, rhythm, eye-trace, the two-dimensional plane of the screen, and three-dimensional space. Whiplash breaks a couple of those on purpose, which is half the fun of rewatching it.
On Sinners, check which version you saw. The Ultra Panavision 70 sections are 2.76:1 and the IMAX sections 1.43:1 on a full IMAX 70mm screen. Digital IMAX rooms show the IMAX sections at 1.90:1, and standard cinemas show the whole film at 2.76:1. Same film, three different experiences of the frame. Say which one you saw when you post about the composition.