On set the dailies looked great: the DIT had a show LUT and per-scene adjustments. In the grading suite the colourist loaded the same LUT and the image looks flatter and darker. Is the LUT wrong, is the room wrong, or are we missing something from set?
Usually two things together. First, the per-scene adjustments were probably CDLs layered under the show LUT. The colourist needs those CDL values per clip (as CDL or CCC files, or in the EDL), and needs to know which colour space they were made in. Without them the grade starts from the bare LUT. Second, the monitor. A grading room should be a calibrated Rec.709 display with the BT.1886 response at gamma 2.4, in a dim room. Many on-set monitors and laptops run brighter, or at a different gamma, in a much brighter environment. A picture graded on a gamma 2.4 monitor in the dark looks darker when you remember it from a sunny set. Source: ITU-R BT.1886, https://www.itu.int/rec/R-REC-BT.1886
Editorial check: were the dailies made with the CDLs baked in? If so, the editor has spent weeks looking at that look, and so have you, and the director has fallen in love with it. Ask the lab or the DIT for the CDL export now, and in future have it delivered with the dailies every day, so nobody has to rebuild it at the end.
The DIT still had the CDLs, one per clip, made in Log C. Colourist loaded them under the show LUT in the same colour space and the set look came back within an hour. We then spent a day pushing it further, which is what the grade was for anyway. I also watched the result on the calibrated monitor in the dark room before judging anything.